Annick Goutal Musc Nomade vs. Czech & Speake Frankincense & Myrrh

by nathanbranch on January 6, 2009 | COMMENTS

AGMNCSFM.gif

ANNICK GOUTAL MUSC NOMADE: Musc Nomade is an excellent piece of work from the Goutal Les Orientalistes series. I’m not certain why I’ve ignored it up until this point, but it has a casual, semi-sweet charm that takes the sometimes difficult to wear musk and makes it a no-brainer for any occasion.

The scent is fairly linear, so you’re not going to run across any delightful (or undelightful, for that matter) surprises radiating off your skin several hours later. It is what it is, from start to finish, but what it is is a white musk that’s injected with just enough ambery notes (tonka, labdanum, almond) to counterbalance its soapy tendencies, leaving you smelling clean, yet warm and easily approachable.

The gourmand almond element particularly distinguishes Musc Nomade from the majority of its white musk competitors.

Re: “easily approachable” as a descriptive term for a slightly gourmand fragrance — I find that “yummy” and “easily approachable” can often be interchangeable; take, for example, cupcakes: definitely yummy, and certainly very (very!) easy to approach. You don’t even have to sneak up on them . . .

Musc Nomade employs a similar tactic. It lulls the wearer by sitting comfortably on the serving platter of the skin, waiting patiently to be devoured noticed, if not complimented.

CZECH & SPEAKE FRANKINCENSE & MYRRH: Opens with that fresh pine & mint-like one-two punch of true frankincense, then warms by degrees, finishing up with a way musty, after the service Catholic church smell (that would be the myrrh mixed with cedar and sandalwood).

This is an old-school incense fragrance and unlikely to please a post-modern crowd, but Czech & Speake is a self-styled old-school perfume house with traditional looking labels and a deliberately crafted country gentleman image, even though it introduced its first fragrance only about twenty five years ago.

It reminds me a bit of Regina Harris’ Frankincense Myrrh Rose Maroc, except that the Czech & Speake doesn’t have any of that amazing rose that sits at the heart of the Harris fragrance. The one advantage of the Czech & Speake is that it’s a spray cologne and not a thick oil, though I don’t consider that a whole lot of advantage over the long haul.

Summary: Musc Nomade wins by a K.O.

OFF TOPIC:

Art photo for the day:

Art Glass

A glass vase on the kitchen table. The afternoon sunlight hit it just right.


{ 6 comments }

Dane January 7, 2009 at 2:39 pm

LOVE Musc Nomade…took me a while to warm up to it (I had a hard time even smelling it at first), but now i covet a bottle.

Nathan Branch January 7, 2009 at 2:42 pm

Right. I’m beginning to think I unfairly overlooked the 4th release in this series.

Dawn January 7, 2009 at 7:23 pm

Love that pic! Do you remember Astro Pops back in the 70′s? They were those suckers that were a slender cone shape? The vase in the picture looks like a wet Astro Pop. Very cool. :)
Oh and as for Musc Nomade, I wish I got the same scent you did. It burned my nostrils when I spritzed it on to sample it.
Dawn

Nathan Branch January 7, 2009 at 9:04 pm

I remember AstroPops! And yes, you’re absolutely right. Now that you’ve mentioned it, I now see a bright, wet AstroPop in front of the blue sky.
And Musc Nomade burned your nostrils? Wow. It went on so smooth and tame and nearly sweet for me. One of these days, if we ever find ourselves in the same room, I’ll spritz some on and you can let me know if I’m perhaps completely unaware of how I walk about the earth, scorching the nostrils of everyone I pass . . .

Dawn January 8, 2009 at 10:54 am

ROFL you walking nostril burner! Hmmm, wonder what I could wear that would burn your nostrils? Spellbound perhaps? ;0
Have a good day.
p.s. I really wanted the Musc Nomade to work because I love musk perfumes. When I sampled it, I was so disappointed that it didn’t smell the way I expected it to. I know it’s billed as a unisex fragrance, but I found it to be a bit more on the masculine side. I still have a sample left, so I’ll spritz it on my hubby to see if smells different to me on him.

Nathan Branch January 8, 2009 at 11:51 am

Crossing my fingers and hoping it smells fan-frickin-tastic on the hubby, otherwise I’m faced with a serious case of rethinking . . . and I really hate to waste my time thinking.

  • Other Shops & Sites

  • 20 ltd.
  • 25 Park Fashion
  • Agent Provocateur Lingerie
  • Alexander McQueen
  • Alexander Wang
  • Aloha Rag
  • Ami Ami Boutique
  • Amy Brill (Sweaters & More)
  • Anastasia Boutique
  • Anya Hindmarch
  • Anya Ponorovskaya
  • Augustina Boutiques
  • Balenciaga
  • Bambas Handbags
  • Basil Racuk: Fine Leather Accessories
  • Be & D Handbags
  • Bergdorf Goodman
  • Betsy Bensen Metalwork Jewelry
  • BillyKirk Artisan Leather Goods
  • Bing Bang Accessories
  • Blackbird Boutique
  • Black Hound Bakery NY
  • Blue in Green: Men's Fashion
  • Botkier Bags & Shoes
  • Bottega Veneta
  • Browns Fashion UK
  • Bryna Nicole Bags
  • Bulgari
  • Burberry
  • Catherine Malandrino
  • Chanel
  • Chick Downtown
  • Clara Kasavina
  • Coach
  • The Corner (designer fashion)
  • Couture Lab
  • Creatures of Comfort
  • Cycle-Two
  • DAVIS by Ruthie Davis
  • Decades
  • Decades Two
  • Derek Lam
  • Devi Kroell New York
  • Diabro
  • Diane von Furstenberg
  • Diesel
  • Dita Eyewear
  • Dover Street Market
  • DSquared2
  • Edward Bess Cosmetics
  • Elle
  • Erik Schedin
  • Fashion ID
  • Fashionwatch.tv
  • Feng Junk Fashion Accessories
  • Flutter by Jill Golden
  • Franco's Fine ClothierFurla
  • Future Classics Fashion
  • Gargyle
  • Georgina Goodman
  • Ghost Boutique
  • Gilt Groupe
  • Giorgio Armani
  • Giuseppe Zanotti
  • Glam.com
  • Gucci
  • Hard Graft Accessories
  • Haute Look
  • Hermès
  • Iosselliani Jewelry
  • Jake Fashion Boutique
  • Jane Bolinger
  • J Brand Jeans
  • J. Crew
  • Jimmy Choo
  • John Bartlett
  • Kabinett & Kammer: Special Objects
  • Kate Spade
  • Kevyn Aucoin Cosmetics
  • Kooba Handbags
  • Lacoste
  • La Garçonne Boutique
  • Laudi Vidni DIY Handbags
  • Le'Bulga handbags
  • Le Silla
  • Linea Pelle
  • Loewe Bags & Accessories
  • Longchamp Paris
  • Lorelei Bags
  • Louis Vuitton
  • Luisa Viaroma Boutique
  • Madewell Clothing & Jeans
  • Marissa Collections
  • Marni
  • Mast Brothers Chocolate
  • Matches Fashion UK
  • Matthew Williamson
  • Me Me Me Boutique
  • Michael Kors
  • Michael Marcus Cosmetics
  • Mona Moore Runway Fashion
  • Moscot Eyewear
  • Mulberry
  • My Catwalk
  • My Theresa Boutique
  • My Wardrobe
  • Need Supply Co.
  • Neiman Marcus
  • Net A Porter
  • Nordstrom
  • Occulter (experimental jewelry)
  • Odin New York
  • Oki-Ni Men's Fashion
  • Opening Ceremony
  • Otte NYC
  • The Outnet
  • Pamela Love
  • Paul Smith
  • Pendleton Wool
  • Pollyanna Fashion
  • Polyvore Trends & Styles
  • Poste Men's Shoes
  • Ralph Lauren
  • Reborn
  • Refinery 29
  • Roberto Cavalli
  • Ron Herman
  • Ron Robinson
  • Rush Patisserie
  • Saks Fifth Avenue
  • Salvatore Ferragamo
  • Scoop NYC
  • Scotch and Soda
  • Searle
  • Sergio Rossi
  • Shoe Runway
  • ShopBop
  • Stella McCartney
  • Stubbs & Wootton
  • TenOverSix Accessories Boutique
  • Tobi Fashion
  • TopShop
  • Tory Burch
  • Trippen Shoes
  • Valentino Online
  • Valet Magazine (Men's Style)
  • Varda Shoes
  • Verso Fashion & Fragrance
  • Vintage Sunglasses
  • Vintage Textile & Couture
  • Vivre Boutique
  • VPL
  • We Are Handsome Swimwear
  • Worthwhile
  • Yigal Azrouel
  • YOOX
  • Yves Saint Laurent
  • Zappos Shoes
  • Zoe Boutique